Skip to content

Catted vs Catless Downpipe: Power, Sound, Legality & Cost

by AutoTalent 29 Oct 2026 0 Comments

Quick answer: A catted downpipe swaps the restrictive factory converter for a high-flow catalytic converter. You get most of the power gain while keeping emissions equipment in place, with less smell and drone. A catless downpipe removes the converter completely. It flows the most, sounds the loudest and costs the least, but it is sold for off-road and competition use only and nearly always needs a tune to avoid check-engine lights. For a daily-driven, registered street car, catted is the right call. Catless only makes sense for a dedicated track or race car.

A downpipe is the first section of exhaust after the turbo, and on most modern turbo cars it's the most restrictive part of the system. Our what does a downpipe do guide covers the basics. This post covers the decision that comes after: catted or catless. We'll go through flow, cell counts, sound, check-engine lights, legality and price, using real B58 BMW and Supra downpipes with prices from AutoTalent at the time of writing.

Catted and catless stainless steel turbo downpipes side by side on a workbench, with a BMW sedan on a lift behind

Catted vs Catless Downpipe at a Glance

Catted (high-flow cat) Catless
What it is Larger-diameter pipe with a high-flow catalytic converter Larger-diameter straight pipe, no converter
Flow Much better than stock; a small step behind catless Maximum flow
Sound Deeper and louder than stock, still civil Loudest, raspiest, more drone
Exhaust smell Close to stock Strong raw-exhaust smell, especially at cold start
Check-engine light Some designs can avoid one; a tune is often still needed Nearly always needs a tune to avoid one
Emissions and legality Keeps a converter; some are EPA registered (state rules vary) Off-road and competition use only
Price (B58 example) About $480 to $1,425 About $300 to $420
Best for Daily drivers, Stage 2 street builds Dedicated track and race cars

How Each Design Works

A factory downpipe has to pass emissions on day one and for the life of the car, so it uses a dense converter close to the turbo. That density creates back pressure, which slows turbo spool and holds heat in the turbine housing.

An aftermarket catted downpipe uses a larger pipe and a high-flow converter. "High-flow" usually means a metallic substrate with fewer, larger cells, so exhaust passes through more easily while the converter still does its job. A catless downpipe is the same larger pipe with no converter at all, so nothing slows the exhaust between the turbo and the mid-pipe.

Mechanic tightening the turbo flange on a catted stainless steel downpipe under a car on a lift

Cell Count: What 200-Cell and 400 CPSI Mean

Converter density is measured in cells per square inch (cpsi). More cells clean the exhaust more thoroughly but restrict more. Fewer cells flow more but clean less. The two catted designs we sell for the B58 show the range:

  • VRSF High Flow Catted: a 200-cell high-flow cat in a 4.5" 304 stainless pipe. It's the more aggressive, flow-first option.
  • Active Autowerke GESI: a 4.5" GESI converter at 400 cpsi, which the manufacturer lists as EPA registered and "NO CEL." It's the more emissions-focused option.

Catless has no cells and the least restriction. On a stock-turbo street car, the step from a high-flow cat to catless is smaller than the step from stock to either one, because most of the gain comes from the bigger pipe and the tune.

Power: How Much Do You Lose With a Cat?

Manufacturers usually publish downpipe gains together with a tune, so use these as manufacturer figures rather than guarantees:

  • VRSF quotes 25 to 30 hp from its B58 downpipe on the G20 M340i and G22 M440i with a tune.
  • VRSF quotes up to 100 whp and 89 lb-ft for its A90 Supra downpipe with a remap.
  • VRSF quotes 20 to 25 hp and 25 to 30 lb-ft at the wheels for its S55 downpipes on the F80 M3, F82 M4 and M2 Competition.

The catless version is the less restrictive of the two, but the extra power over a high-flow cat depends on the car, the turbo and how far the tune pushes it. On a factory turbo, a quality high-flow catted downpipe gets you most of the way. If you're chasing every last pound on a big-turbo build, catless gives you the most headroom.

Sound, Drone and Smell

Both versions make the car louder because the downpipe is the first thing the exhaust hits after the turbo. A catted downpipe deepens the tone and brings out more turbo noise and pops on a tune, while staying close to stock for smell. A catless downpipe is noticeably louder and raspier, can add drone on the highway, and gives a strong raw-exhaust smell, especially at cold start and in a garage. If you live with the car every day, that difference matters more than it sounds.

Check-Engine Lights and Tuning

Modern cars use a rear oxygen sensor after the converter to check converter efficiency. If the converter flows too freely, or is gone, the ECU flags it.

  • Catless: expect a check-engine light without a tune that handles the rear O2 sensor.
  • Catted: a denser high-flow cat can stay quiet. Active Autowerke lists its GESI B58 downpipe as "NO CEL." A 200-cell cat may still need a tune. VRSF states a tune is required for both its catted and catless B58 downpipes.

Either way, a downpipe is what usually moves a car from Stage 1 to Stage 2. That means the tune has to match the hardware, as covered in our Stage 1 vs Stage 2 tune guide.

Is a Catless Downpipe Legal?

Not on a street car. Under the federal Clean Air Act, removing or disabling emissions equipment on a vehicle used on public roads isn't allowed, and that's why catless downpipes are sold for off-road and competition use only. Cars in emissions-testing states will typically fail inspection without a converter.

Catted downpipes keep a converter, but the details still matter. Active Autowerke lists its GESI downpipes as EPA registered and legal in 49 states, except California. If you're in California or a state that follows its rules, check whether a part carries a CARB Executive Order before buying.

Cutaway of a high-flow metallic catalytic converter showing its honeycomb cells next to a straight catless pipe

Price: Catted vs Catless on the B58

Here's how the B58 options we stock compare, with prices on AutoTalent at the time of writing:

Downpipe Type Price
VRSF B58 Downpipe (M340i, M440i and more) Track Limited Racing (catless) $299.99 brushed, $419.99 with heat shield
VRSF B58 Downpipe (M340i, M440i and more) High Flow Catted (200-cell) $479.99 brushed, $579.99 with heat shield
VRSF A90 Supra 3.0 B58 Downpipe Catless or 200-cell catted Same pricing as the BMW version
Active Autowerke G20 M340i / G22 M440i GESI Downpipe GESI catted, 400 cpsi $1,424.05
Active Autowerke A90 Supra 3.0 GESI Downpipe GESI catted, 400 cpsi $1,424.05

Fitment note: the Active Autowerke G20/G22 downpipe covers 2020 to 2024 M340i and M440i models. 2025 and newer cars use the updated B58 with a particulate filter, so check fitment on every product page against your car's exact model year.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Daily driver, registered, any state with inspections: catted. The GESI style is the emissions-focused pick, and a 200-cell high-flow cat is the flow-focused pick.
  • Stage 2 street build on a stock turbo: catted. You keep most of the gain with far less smell and drone.
  • Dedicated track, race or off-road car: catless gives the most flow and the lowest price.
  • California: only parts with a CARB Executive Order are street legal there.

Browse every high-flow option in our catted downpipe collection, or see the competition-only options in our catless downpipe collection.

FAQ

Is a catted or catless downpipe better?

For a street car, catted is better: it keeps a catalytic converter, smells and drones less and avoids most emissions problems while still delivering most of the power. Catless only makes sense on a dedicated track or race car.

Does a catless downpipe need a tune?

Almost always. Without a converter, the rear oxygen sensor reports a problem and the car sets a check-engine light, so a tune that handles the rear O2 sensor is needed.

Will a catted downpipe throw a check-engine light?

It depends on the converter. Denser high-flow cats such as Active Autowerke's 400 cpsi GESI downpipe are listed as no-CEL, while 200-cell high-flow cats may still need a tune. VRSF states a tune is required for both its catted and catless B58 downpipes.

Is a catless downpipe street legal?

No. Removing emissions equipment from a vehicle used on public roads isn't allowed under the federal Clean Air Act, so catless downpipes are sold for off-road and competition use only.

How much power do you lose with a catted downpipe?

Usually not much on a stock turbo. Most of the gain comes from the larger pipe and the tune, so a quality high-flow catted downpipe gets most of the way, and catless adds the most headroom on bigger-turbo builds.

Is a catted downpipe louder than stock?

Yes. Any aftermarket downpipe adds volume and turbo sound, but a catted downpipe stays much more civil than catless, with less drone and less exhaust smell.

Prev Post
Next Post

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Login Close
Close
Shopping Cart
1 items

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose Options

Recently Viewed

Close
Edit Option
Close
Back In Stock Notification
this is just a warning